SHOCKED REACTION: Jason Kelce Left Speechless as Wyatt Requests a Cat Like Taylor Swift’s Aunt’s on Podcast

In the latest episode of New Heights, Jason Kelce found himself in one of the most unfiltered—and unexpectedly hilarious—family moments yet.

The retired Philadelphia Eagles center was left completely stunned when his 5-year-old daughter, Wyatt, casually chimed in with a request that caught everyone off guard: she wanted a cat, but not just any cat—she wanted one “like Aunt Taylor’s aunt has.”

Listeners could practically hear Jason’s jaw drop as he tried to process the oddly specific demand.

Known for his larger-than-life personality and no-nonsense takes on the podcast he co-hosts with younger brother Travis Kelce, Jason was uncharacteristically lost for words.

“Wait… what? Whose cat?” Jason asked, his voice tinged with confusion as Wyatt doubled down, insisting she wanted a feline companion “just like the one in the family.”

Fans immediately assumed Wyatt was referring to Taylor Swift’s extended family, sparking a wave of laughter and lighthearted chatter across social media.

The moment spread quickly among the New Heights community, with clips replayed and memed within hours.

“Jason Kelce looking absolutely bamboozled by a 5-year-old might be the funniest thing I’ve heard all week,” one fan wrote on X (formerly Twitter).

Another added, “Wyatt is already podcast gold—give that kid her own segment.”

The exchange highlights what fans have come to love most about New Heights: its authenticity.

While the Kelce brothers often talk football, rivalries, and locker room life, it’s the candid family moments—Wyatt’s guest appearances, Kylie Kelce’s cameos, and now Wyatt’s unexpected cat request—that steal the show.

Whether Jason will cave in and actually bring a cat into the Kelce household remains to be seen.

But one thing is certain: Wyatt knows exactly how to keep her dad—and millions of listeners—on their toes.

As fans continue replaying the viral moment, one question lingers: Will the Kelces soon be introducing a new furry family member to the podcast lineup?